Chelsea and Josh met the old fashioned way: the dating app Hinge. Josh won Chelsea over with what was, admittedly, the refreshingly normal opening line: “Hey, have you ever been to City Park Jazz?” Which, sadly, was a refreshingly normal question to ask a stranger enough to exchange numbers and go on a date. Their first date was at The Thin Man, which is where Josh eventually proposed (around the corner). Over beers, they discussed similar interests in music, movies, shared midwest upbringings, and the general state of the world (not good).